Attaining Social Maturity & The Future of the Groundswell: Toys R Us

As we conclude our reading of Li and Bernoff's Groundswell, we can piece together the final steps that a company must take to embrace and strengthen the groundswell. Companies that maintain a shift in their mindset and embrace change will succeed, while companies that do not make the shift or put in the necessary effort will fail.

Toys R Us is an example of a company that failed to invest in the future of its groundswell. In the past 10 years or so, we have seen major companies rise and pass the toy company's level of success. Toys R Us did not take the proper steps towards preserving its groundswell, and competitors like Amazon, Walmart, and Target ended up on top. 

The toy company struggled to keep up with changing trends in consumer behavior, which led to the liquidation of the company in 2018. As price differentiations from top competitors were a major factor, it also had a lot to do with Toys R Us's failure to innovate its business model and incorporate new technologies. As a company that used to be the top toy distributor that was in touch with its groundswell, making birthday calls to its customers and providing its members with special deals, it is sad to have watched the company fail so drastically.

According to the Wharton School, companies have to morph and modify, and they must represent changes in the marketplace as well as their customers' behavior. Toys R Us was unable to make the necessary changes to allow the company to succeed. This is incredibly similar to what Li and Bernoff have said in Groundswell about mindset shifts. In chapter 14, the authors state that groundswell technologies must be integrated into the company's everyday life and marketing strategies. Businesses must remain continually connected to their customers through social networks, real-time feedback, and personalized content. Mark Cohen from Wharton stated that "there was no consequential effort to re-imagine themselves, to present themselves in a more engaging and attractive way." Customers who were once fully engaged in the toy company's groundswell began to switch over to other brands. Stores like Target and Walmart became more appealing. If a customer could purchase toys and their groceries at the same time, of course, they would abandon the only option that only sold toys. A customer's shopping experience is essential, and Toys R Us did not get the memo. The stores were poorly organized, overstocked, and overpriced, especially in comparison to their competitors. They were unable to keep up. 

The biggest area where Toys R Us failed to adapt would be the digital market. As more children and teens shifted to playing online games, and more parents shifted to shopping online, Toys R Us remained the same. They did not succeed when it came to establishing an online presence, and they became irrelevant. The company did not keep up with their groundswell in the ways that they needed to. They lacked social maturity and stayed in the dormant stage. There was virtually no social connection with their groundswell, and it led to their demise. 

Did you use to shop at Toys R Us? What do you think they could have done differently to prevent this? Do you think it even could have been possible for them to stay alive in today's digital climate?

Comments

  1. If Toys R Us had focused on creating a seamless omnichannel experience, combining in-store excitement with online convenience they may have retained more customer loyalty. For example, they could have integrated online pre-orders with in-store pick-ups, developed interactive apps or gaming partnerships for kids, and personalized promotions based on customer behavior. This would have allowed them to maintain a strong connection with their groundswell while keeping up with changing consumer habits.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Toys R Us is a great example of what not to do! Although it is nostalgic for me, it is important to put that aside to look at the full context. They didn't fail because they were a toy store. They failed because they were outdated and didn't bother listening to their groundswell and the changing world. Due to this, it began to feel stale, with no point to supporting them anymore. If they had listened to their groundswell and changed with the world, I bet they'd at least lasted longer.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Daniella,
    This was a topic that I knew about, but wasn't very close to, as I probably went to toys r us only 2 or 3 times before its closing. Before this I had assumed that Amazon and online ordering is what killed the company, and that there was nothing they could have done to stop it. But you make a great point that Toys R Us did not do the necessary work to incorporate new technologies into their decision-making and business model. It reminds me of the authors' point that, whether a company addresses it or not, the groundswell WILL come and impact a brand, and it's their job to prepare, or not prepare, for it.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts